ESGrecht – horak Rechtsanwälte

Home

ESG insights and case law: archive 2023–2026

Explore 48 articles across four years, each with practical examples, official sources and an assessment updated on 15 November 2026.

These archive articles were prepared retrospectively. Their assigned dates identify the relevant topic period. For 2026, the 12 articles cover January to 15 November.

2026

12 articles

2026-11-15 · Supply chains and human rights

EUDR in November 2026: making year-end preparation concrete

Ahead of the next EUDR application date, businesses should finalise scope and data-process checks. Product, role, size and the applicable transition are decisive.

Read article →

2026-11-03 · Finance and ESG ratings

ESG ratings in November 2026: checking provider status after the deadline

Expiry of the transitional period makes ESG-rating providers’ regulatory status a concrete review task. Providers and users must identify the applicable access regime.

Read article →

2026-10-22 · Governance and compliance

Climate targets in 2026: commitments that remain relevant after Omnibus

Removal of a particular statutory planning duty does not make every climate commitment legally irrelevant. Contracts, advertising and governance require separate assessment.

Read article →

2026-09-28 · Case law and remedies

Environmental advertising from September 2026: claims, labels and existing stock

New sustainability advertising rules change product and campaign approval. Businesses need a specific assessment of each claim and its use.

Read article →

2026-08-13 · Environment and products

PPWR from August 2026: allocating packaging duties by role and date

General application of the PPWR makes precise allocation of duties particularly important. Requirements do not all begin simultaneously, and different roles carry different responsibilities.

Read article →

2026-07-03 · Finance and ESG ratings

ESG ratings from July 2026: provider duties and rated companies’ rights

European ESG-rating regulation affects providers, users and rated companies differently. A rating is neither a general sustainability certificate nor a guarantee of legal compliance.

Read article →

2026-06-23 · Case law and remedies

ESG procurement in 2026: preparing remedies before contract award

Sustainability criteria can determine a tender’s outcome. Challenging their design or evaluation requires coordination of substantive arguments and procedural deadlines.

Read article →

2026-05-28 · Environment and products

EPBD in 2026: what the transposition deadline means for property decisions

The European implementation deadline prompts renewed review of long-term property projects. It does not mean an identical immediate renovation duty for every asset.

Read article →

2026-04-21 · Environment and products

Repair rights in 2026: aligning service contracts and product processes

European repair rules connect sustainability with specific consumer and manufacturer obligations. Businesses must distinguish seller liability, separate repair duties and technical product rules.

Read article →

2026-03-19 · Supply chains and human rights

CSDDD in 2026: narrower scope, a new timetable and targeted due diligence

Reform changes both timing and the reach and design of European due diligence. Existing supply chain projects therefore need a targeted reassessment.

Read article →

2026-02-26 · Reporting and strategy

CSRD reform in 2026: assessing reporting duties under the new thresholds

The final Omnibus reform substantially changes regular reporting scope. Fresh assessment depends on entity, group, financial year and national implementation.

Read article →

2026-01-15 · Environment and products

CBAM in 2026: moving from transitional reporting to the definitive system

Since the start of 2026, CBAM can no longer be treated solely as a historical reporting project. Import planning, authorisation and emissions information must be coordinated.

Read article →

2025

12 articles

2025-12-11 · Reporting and strategy

Omnibus at the end of 2025: distinguishing political agreement from binding law

The December 2025 political agreement clarified the direction of ESG reform. Binding corporate decisions still needed to account for formal completion of the legislative process.

Read article →

2025-11-18 · Governance and compliance

ESG clauses in 2025: defining evidence, audits and liability in supply contracts

ESG requirements are often passed through purchasing terms. Both sides benefit from duties that are understandable, achievable and connected to appropriate remedies.

Read article →

2025-10-21 · Environment and products

CBAM reform in 2025: calculating the 50-tonne threshold correctly

CBAM simplification aimed particularly to relieve small import volumes. Businesses must apply the threshold to the correct goods and importer.

Read article →

2025-09-29 · Supply chains and human rights

BAFA in 2025: stopping report checks did not end all due diligence

Announced restraint under the Supply Chain Act changed enforcement practice. Businesses also needed to avoid treating an enforcement decision as wholesale statutory repeal.

Read article →

2025-08-19 · Reporting and strategy

ESRS quick-fix in 2025: reviewing relief for first-wave reporters

The ESRS quick-fix aimed to provide additional relief for companies already reporting. It differed from postponement of later waves and from complete exemption.

Read article →

2025-07-21 · Supply chains and human rights

Battery due diligence in 2025: two extra years without suspending product duties

Postponement of battery due diligence eased preparation. Product teams also needed to identify the requirements that the change did not affect.

Read article →

2025-06-18 · Supply chains and human rights

EUDR country risk in 2025: low risk does not mean complete exemption

European country benchmarking assists risk-based organisation of deforestation-free supply chains. It does not replace review of the particular goods and their origin.

Read article →

2025-05-29 · Case law and remedies

OLG Hamm in 2025: what the RWE climate case shows about liability and proof

The RWE climate decision distinguishes a potentially available legal basis from proof of its specific conditions. That distinction is essential for businesses and claimants.

Read article →

2025-04-17 · Reporting and strategy

Stop-the-clock in 2025: translating postponed duties into project decisions

The first binding Omnibus relief concerned timing. Businesses needed to establish precisely whether their reporting wave or due diligence plan was affected.

Read article →

2025-03-18 · Governance and compliance

ESG data in 2025: lawful use of employee information and supply chain evidence

Sustainability data are not automatically available for unrestricted use. Social indicators, complaints and audit records may contain personal or particularly sensitive information.

Read article →

2025-02-27 · Reporting and strategy

Omnibus in 2025: why a reform proposal did not create an exemption

The Omnibus proposals created significant uncertainty for ongoing ESG projects in 2025. A legally sound response needed to distinguish existing duties from potential future relief.

Read article →

2025-01-27 · Environment and products

PPWR in 2025: incorporating the new packaging regulation into procurement

Publication of the European Packaging Regulation established a binding framework for transition. Businesses needed to start by mapping packaging and market roles.

Read article →

2024

12 articles

2024-12-27 · Supply chains and human rights

EUDR at the end of 2024: the first postponement and its limits

The first postponement of the Deforestation Regulation gave businesses more preparation time. It removed neither the need for origin data nor necessarily customer duties already agreed.

Read article →

2024-11-21 · Supply chains and human rights

Forced labour in 2024: preparing for the EU product ban

The European forced-labour product ban concerns market access. It supplements organisational due diligence with a separate product-based instrument.

Read article →

2024-10-17 · Environment and products

Building law in 2024: energy requirements in sales, leases and projects

Energy-performance requirements affect investment and contracts. Legal assessment must connect the building’s condition and use with applicable national law.

Read article →

2024-09-18 · Reporting and strategy

Sustainability reporting in 2024: organising data approval and responsibility

Preparation for first reports made internal approval quality particularly important in 2024. A report is only as traceable as the processes supporting its statements.

Read article →

2024-08-20 · Environment and products

Nature restoration in 2024: implications for land, projects and permits

European nature restoration affects long-term site and land decisions. Businesses need to connect European objectives with specific national implementation.

Read article →

2024-07-22 · Environment and products

Ecodesign in 2024: what the ESPR means for products and data

The new Ecodesign Regulation broadens attention to durability, repair and circularity. Businesses must nevertheless distinguish the European framework from specific product duties.

Read article →

2024-06-28 · Case law and remedies

The BGH’s 2024 “climate neutral” ruling: explanations belong with the claim

Environmental advertising terms can carry several meanings. The Federal Court of Justice’s climate-neutrality judgment highlighted clear explanation within the advertising context.

Read article →

2024-05-27 · Supply chains and human rights

CSDDD in 2024: understanding the original EU due diligence directive

The European due diligence directive established a new corporate framework in 2024. Reviewing decisions made then requires distinguishing the original provisions from later amendments.

Read article →

2024-04-11 · Case law and remedies

The 2024 ECtHR climate judgment: state protection duties and access to court

The KlimaSeniorinnen judgment demonstrated the human-rights dimension of climate protection. Admissibility, standing and the appropriate procedural route remain decisive in practice.

Read article →

2024-03-20 · Supply chains and human rights

Critical raw materials in 2024: organising supply security in law

Raw material dependencies affect more than purchasing prices. Production disruption, permits, risk assessments and sustainability commitments need a coordinated approach.

Read article →

2024-02-28 · Environment and products

EmpCo in 2024: preparing for new European limits on green advertising

European consumer reform focused on general environmental claims, sustainability labels and carbon offsetting. Businesses needed to start with a complete advertising inventory.

Read article →

2024-01-17 · Supply chains and human rights

LkSG in 2024: the 1,000-employee threshold and its practical effects

The expanded scope brought more businesses directly within supply chain due diligence in 2024. An existing purchasing code now needed to form part of verifiable risk management.

Read article →

2023

12 articles

2023-12-18 · Governance and compliance

Reporting channels for SMEs: the December 2023 whistleblowing deadline

At the end of 2023, the practical availability of internal reporting offices became a priority. The special establishment period ended for many medium-sized employers.

Read article →

2023-11-16 · Environment and products

Energy efficiency in 2023: distinguishing EU policy from operational duties

Energy efficiency law involves more than a savings target. Businesses must connect specific duties, measurement methods and responsibilities with their installations and sites.

Read article →

2023-10-16 · Environment and products

CBAM from October 2023: building traceable import reporting data

The CBAM transition required covered imports to enter a traceable reporting system. The data chain from overseas manufacturer to submission became a central operational issue.

Read article →

2023-09-19 · Governance and compliance

Sustainability cooperation in 2023: protecting joint standards under competition law

Common sustainability standards can improve supply chains. Where competitors coordinate procurement, data or market conduct, the project also needs competition-law assessment.

Read article →

2023-08-21 · Environment and products

The 2023 Batteries Regulation: planning duties across the product life cycle

Batteries connect product compliance, raw material sourcing, consumer information and collection. The new EU regulation therefore called for planning across departments and application dates.

Read article →

2023-07-31 · Reporting and strategy

ESRS in 2023: materiality and data quality before first reporting

The first European sustainability reporting standards made the practical CSRD framework more tangible. Businesses needed a transparent selection of topics and reliable data collection.

Read article →

2023-06-14 · Supply chains and human rights

OECD Guidelines 2023: connecting climate, supply chains and complaints

The updated OECD Guidelines broadened guidance for responsible business conduct. Their practical importance is particularly apparent where business partners, the public and complaints procedures refer to the same corporate commitments.

Read article →

2023-05-31 · Governance and compliance

Germany’s Whistleblower Protection Act in 2023: more than a new inbox

The Whistleblower Protection Act made reporting channels, confidentiality and follow-up an integrated organisational task. A technical mailbox alone cannot perform it.

Read article →

2023-04-27 · Environment and products

CBAM in 2023: what the carbon border adjustment meant for procurement

European agreement on the carbon border adjustment mechanism brought imported goods and emissions data into focus. Preparation started with tariff codes and responsibility.

Read article →

2023-03-16 · Reporting and strategy

CSRD in 2023: define the reporting perimeter before collecting data

The new European sustainability reporting framework first required a clear assessment of scope. Commissioning a complete data catalogue too early can obscure entity, group and transitional questions.

Read article →

2023-02-15 · Finance and ESG ratings

SFDR in 2023: keeping financial product disclosures consistent

Detailed disclosure requirements increased the need to coordinate product design, data collection and distribution in 2023. A green product name does not replace a verifiable investment description.

Read article →

2023-01-16 · Supply chains and human rights

The LkSG in 2023: organising the start of supply chain duties

The German Supply Chain Due Diligence Act turned general sustainability ambitions into binding organisational duties for businesses within scope. Specific risks and proportionate action were central.

Read article →

Your next step