ESGrecht – horak Rechtsanwälte

Home / Insights / 2025

Case law and remedies

OLG Hamm in 2025: what the RWE climate case shows about liability and proof

The RWE climate decision distinguishes a potentially available legal basis from proof of its specific conditions. That distinction is essential for businesses and claimants.

Archive allocation: 2025-05-29. Prepared retrospectively and legally reviewed on 15 November 2026. The archive date identifies the topic’s period, not an earlier publication. Historical developments and the current assessment are distinguished below.

Case law and remedies · Climate law · Legal remedies · Corporate governance

On 28 May 2025, OLG Hamm dismissed the appeal in case 5 U 15/17. It nevertheless did not exclude liability of a CO₂ emitter under section 1004 BGB in principle. A specific, location- and situation-based interference with property or threat remained decisive. The judgment neither rules out all liability nor orders RWE to make the payment sought.

Implementation and potential disputes

Climate litigation requires precise identification of the claim, interference, attribution and remedy. Global emissions data and local hazard forecasts serve different purposes. Expert evidence must address the specific question of proof. An emitter’s size does not replace all conditions of individual liability.

Defence requires timely preparation of facts, technical foundations and objections. Insurance, provisions and public communications cannot replace procedural assessment. Appeals on fact and law differ from appeals on points of law; permission and further remedies require examination of the particular decision.

Four practical examples

Illustrative scenarios, not accounts of completed client matters.

1. An owner relies on general climate models

Assessment connects them to the particular local hazard. General risks are not automatically treated as an individual interference.

2. A business relies only on its permits

The legal significance of permits is examined. Public-law authorisation does not automatically resolve every civil-liability question.

3. Experts reach different conclusions

Assumptions, data and questions of proof are compared. Methodological objections are made specifically rather than generically.

4. Settlement is considered

Costs, measures, admissions and enforceability are addressed. The agreement should avoid unintended commitments for other situations.

Position today

The judgment is an important individual case on climate-related property liability. Different claimants, damage or facts may require different analysis; it cannot support a general prediction of success.

Documents for review

Claim letters, title records, expert reports, emissions records, permits and insurance contracts support assessment.

Official sources

Related specialist guidance

Discuss your ESG matter

Tell us about your question or dispute. All enquiry fields are optional.