ESGrecht – horak Rechtsanwälte

Home / Business & responsibility

Business & responsibility

ESG data, privacy, trade secrets and AI

ESG projects need data from many functions. We assess collection, exchange, analysis and publication and draft contracts for software, data providers and AI-supported applications.

Data quality and lawful purpose

Before collecting data, its intended purpose must be established. Statutory reporting, supplier audits, workforce management and advertising are different purposes. Not every item of interest for an ESG report may be processed without limit. Data minimisation and transparent boundaries support both legal certainty and technical quality.

Personal data must be distinguished from purely corporate information. Even aggregated figures may identify individuals in small groups. Health information, trade union membership and certain diversity characteristics are subject to special requirements. A general interest in sustainability does not replace a necessary legal basis.

Providers, groups and third countries

For software and platform services, we identify the controller, joint controllers or processor. Contracts, actual decision-making powers and data flows must align. Subprocessors, deletion, assistance with individual rights and security measures form part of the review. A provider’s description alone does not establish the legal classification.

Data protection requirements also apply to intra-group exchanges. Transfers to third countries need the relevant legal conditions; shared branding does not remove them. Technical access controls, encryption and limited analyses can reduce risks. Trade secrets and competitively sensitive information require additional protection.

AI for reporting and risk analysis

AI can structure text or analyse datasets, but does not automatically produce accurate facts or legal assessments. Each system is assessed for purpose, input data, rights in outputs, confidentiality and human oversight. Incorrect attribution can be particularly consequential in sensitive supplier or employee evaluations.

The AI Act must be assessed by role, system type and applicable implementation stage. Not every ESG tool is a high-risk system; conversely, employment-related use can trigger special requirements. Provider and deployer duties differ. A technical product label cannot replace this functional assessment.

Authorities, individual rights and liability

Privacy complaints and access requests require assessment of competence, timing and scope. Internal investigations do not generally justify refusing every individual right. Confidentiality, third-party rights and statutory exceptions must be balanced specifically. Personal data breaches require separate assessment of reporting and notification duties.

Supervisory measures and fines have different remedies. Civil injunction and compensation claims may arise as well. Incorrect ESG data can also require notifying contractual partners or correcting reports. One data error may therefore trigger several procedures requiring coordinated handling.

Four practical examples

The following examples are illustrative scenarios, not accounts of completed client matters.

Example 1: Diversity data in a report

A business wants to publish detailed characteristics of small teams. Assessment covers legal basis, re-identification and the information actually needed. Greater aggregation may provide information without identifying individuals. Consent must be voluntary and valid for the specific purpose.

Example 2: Supplier data in an AI service

Procurement teams upload contracts and audit reports to an external system. We review terms, training uses, storage and third-country access. Inputs may need restriction or an appropriate enterprise arrangement. Merely hoping for confidentiality is not an adequate contractual provision.

Example 3: Incorrect risk scoring

A supplier is excluded on the basis of outdated data. Sources, currency and decision-making are examined. Contractual claims and legal limits on automated assessments require review. Human approval must be substantive, rather than a purely formal confirmation on a screen.

Example 4: A reporting portal data breach

Reports and identities become accessible without authorisation. Immediate measures, evidence preservation and statutory reporting questions are coordinated. Investigation establishes responsibility and extent. Notifications to affected persons must be accurate and should not unnecessarily disclose additional confidential information.

Related topics

Contact

Your next step in ESG law.

Whether your matter concerns contracts, regulatory proceedings or a dispute, tell us what you need. We will clarify the legal issues and next steps with you.

horak Rechtsanwälte Partnerschaft mbB · Georgstraße 48 · 30159 Hannover