ESGrecht – horak Rechtsanwälte

Home / Supply chains & products

Supply chains & products

Sustainable products, ecodesign and the circular economy

Sustainability requirements follow a product from development to disposal. We assess market access, labelling, repairability, product information and legal responsibility within the supply chain.

Classifying products and economic operators

Manufacturers, importers, distributors and authorised representatives have different duties. Selling a product under one’s own brand or substantially modifying it can create additional responsibility. Assessment therefore starts with product type, intended use, sales territory and supply structure. General product safety, sector-specific rules and sustainability duties apply alongside one another.

Ecodesign Regulation (EU) 2024/1781 establishes a framework for product-specific sustainability requirements. Not every possible obligation already applies to every product group. Specific requirements, digital product passports and transitional periods derive from the relevant framework and implementing measures. The same applies to special rules for batteries, electrical equipment or packaging.

Development, materials and product information

Repairability, durability, spare parts, recycled content and substance restrictions should be considered early in development and procurement. Technical feasibility and legal permissibility are different questions. A recycled material may be environmentally desirable yet require additional chemical or safety assessments. Improving sustainability must not result in an unsafe product.

Product information must reflect the actual product. Digital product data require arrangements for responsibilities, updates, access and protection of confidential information. Advertising claims are additionally subject to misleading advertising rules. A legally required characteristic should not be promoted as a special voluntary environmental advantage without assessment.

Contracts and responsibility

Supply contracts should address material specifications, documentation, change management and traceability. Review and approval processes must identify when changes of material or production location require notification. Using a technical standard may facilitate proof, but does not replace every legal assessment.

Defects or safety risks engage contract law, product liability and regulatory powers. Internal allocation of costs is separate from the duty to take immediate protective measures. A recall requires coordination of communications, product containment, notifications and recourse. Insurance terms and policyholder duties should be considered early.

Authorities may request information, undertake inspections and, depending on the legal basis, restrict distribution or order other measures. Before responding, the addressee, competence, specific requirements and enforceability need clarification. A hearing and technical response may influence the decision. Binding measures require assessment of the appropriate remedy and, where necessary, administrative interim relief.

Competitors or other entitled parties may also seek injunctions, while buyers may exercise warranty rights. Administrative fines follow separate procedural rules. Successfully challenging a regulatory order does not automatically determine a parallel civil claim.

Four practical examples

The following examples are illustrative scenarios, not accounts of completed client matters.

Example 1: Recycled plastic in a series product

A manufacturer replaces conventional plastic with recycled material. Assessment covers chemicals law, safety, promised characteristics and labelling. Supplier evidence is combined with the manufacturer’s own testing. Only then can the permitted environmental claim and any changes to customer approvals or certifications be determined.

Example 2: A digital product passport

An importer needs to provide product data from several countries. We clarify the product-specific requirements actually applicable and allocate responsibilities. Data quality, access rights and updates are agreed contractually. Buying software alone does not fulfil an obligation if required information is incomplete or unreliable.

Example 3: A distribution ban

A market surveillance authority objects to missing information. Alongside the substantive requirement, the order’s scope and proportionality are examined. Depending on the circumstances, correction, a narrower measure or interim relief may be appropriate. Continuing enforceability must not be overlooked during legal review.

Example 4: A spare parts promise is not honoured

A business advertises long-term repairability but discontinues spare parts early. Assessment covers the statement’s binding effect, contractual duties and potential misleading advertising. Procurement, servicing and communications need a coordinated solution. A general reference to supply difficulties does not automatically extinguish existing duties.

Related topics

Contact

Your next step in ESG law.

Whether your matter concerns contracts, regulatory proceedings or a dispute, tell us what you need. We will clarify the legal issues and next steps with you.

horak Rechtsanwälte Partnerschaft mbB · Georgstraße 48 · 30159 Hannover