ESGrecht – horak Rechtsanwälte

Home / Human rights

Human rights

Forced labour: product bans and supply chain controls

Indications of forced labour can immediately affect supply chains, trade and customer relationships. Businesses must distinguish due diligence duties, specific product bans and contractual promises. An audit alone does not answer these questions.

Understanding the EU product ban

Regulation (EU) 2024/3015 generally applies from 14 December 2027. It covers products made with forced labour inside or outside the EU, including exports. Services as such are outside this product ban. The Regulation does not create a general independent duty for every business to undertake new regular audits or reports. Other due diligence, reporting and cooperation obligations require separate assessment.

Investigation responsibility depends in particular on where the suspected forced labour occurs: the Commission is competent outside the EU, while the relevant national authority generally leads within it. Responding reliably to official questions requires identification of products, production facilities and relevant upstream suppliers. Unsupported assurances are of little help when specific origin data are requested.

Documenting supply chains reliably

Practical preparation combines risk indicators, material flows, working conditions and existing complaints channels. Relevant signs may include retained identity documents, recruitment fees, forced overtime or movement restrictions. Investigations must protect affected people and avoid creating new risks through premature contact.

Contracts should specifically regulate information access, evidence, remediation, costs and supply interruption consequences. Supplier recourse requires an appropriate legal basis and coherent evidence. Continuing, suspending or ending a relationship requires assessment of legal and practical effects. A blanket guarantee covering an unknown entire chain can create substantial additional liability.

Proceedings and remedies

An investigation requires preservation of its precise subject, competent body, response periods and confidential records. Commission decisions are challenged under EU conditions, particularly for annulment and possible interim relief. National enforcement acts follow the relevant domestic procedure. Review of the substantive decision and provisional protection are separate matters.

US imports additionally require assessment of the UFLPA and US customs procedure. The statutory presumption for particular origin and entity connections differs from the EU process. German supply contracts and European certification do not automatically remove US import barriers. See international supply chains for coordination.

Four practical examples

The following examples are illustrative scenarios, not accounts of completed client matters.

Example 1: Concerns at a textile supplier

A customer receives reports that passports are retained at a factory. Evidence is first preserved and risks to workers assessed. A coordinated investigation and remediation plan follows. Supply stoppages and termination are not declared without reviewing contractual and practical consequences.

Example 2: One component prevents US import

A machinery manufacturer cannot fully evidence an input’s origin. With counsel responsible for US law, it clarifies whether the presumption applies or an exception must be demonstrated. Supplier claims and replacement procurement are assessed in parallel.

Example 3: An official product investigation

An authority requests information on a product series. The business links batches, purchase records and production evidence. Its response separates established facts from unresolved matters and identifies trade secrets. The remedy route is prepared for a possible adverse decision.

Example 4: A customer requests an unlimited guarantee

A supplier is asked to guarantee absence of forced labour at every upstream stage worldwide. The clause is assessed against control and liability consequences. Negotiations focus on verifiable procedures, specific information duties and graduated remediation rights instead of an uncontrollable guarantee of results.

Related topics

Contact

Your next step in ESG law.

Whether your matter concerns contracts, regulatory proceedings or a dispute, tell us what you need. We will clarify the legal issues and next steps with you.

horak Rechtsanwälte Partnerschaft mbB · Georgstraße 48 · 30159 Hannover