ESGrecht – horak Rechtsanwälte

Home / Proceedings & remedies

Proceedings & remedies

Procurement review, complaints and immediate appeals

Unlawful sustainability criteria or unjustified exclusion may require rapid protection. We assess complaints to contracting authorities, review applications, appeals and their current effects on contract award.

Scope and standing

GWB review proceedings require, among other conditions, a covered procurement and the relevant thresholds. Applicants must show an interest in the contract, a possible infringement of their procurement rights and actual or threatened damage. A general interest in better sustainability is insufficient. Additional statutory restrictions must also be considered.

Below EU thresholds, jurisdiction and protection follow the applicable rules. State-law review mechanisms, civil proceedings and administrative proceedings must not be treated as equivalent. A supervisory complaint also has a different effect from a court application.

Complaints and deadlines

A recognised infringement generally must be raised with the contracting authority within ten calendar days. Infringements apparent from the notice or tender documents generally must be challenged no later than the relevant participation or tender deadline. Statutory exceptions and interaction with other periods require separate review.

Following notification that the authority will not remedy a complaint, the 15-calendar-day period in section 160(3) GWB is particularly important. The complaint should identify the specific error and requested correction. A bidder question is not necessarily a formal complaint. Pre-award information and standstill duties under section 134 GWB require separate assessment.

Application and review chamber proceedings

The application must substantiate facts, infringement and the remedy sought. Subject to statutory conditions, service by the review chamber may trigger an award prohibition. Merely sending an application or complaint must not be equated with secured award protection without checking. The current procurement stage therefore needs immediate clarification.

File access may provide important information but is limited by other bidders’ confidentiality. Written submissions, hearings and decisions follow an accelerated procedure. The chamber may order suitable corrective measures; not every established error automatically creates an entitlement to the contract.

Immediate appeal and current effect on award

The decision generally may be appealed to the competent Higher Regional Court within two weeks. Section 172 GWB requires the appeal to include its grounds at the same time. This differs from remedies with a later separate reasoning period. Representation and notification duties towards the other participants must be observed.

Under the currently available wording of section 173(1) GWB, an immediate appeal against rejection of a review application has no suspensive effect. Parties must therefore not rely on the automatic protective period described in older materials. Interim relief, award status and applicable transitional law require immediate assessment against the actual procedure. Where the chamber prohibited award, section 173(2) contains a separate rule.

After award and costs

A validly awarded contract can be challenged only under special conditions. Section 135 GWB contains limited grounds of ineffectiveness and separate periods. Damages claims differ from primary correction of the procurement. Fees, legal costs and risks from abusive applications form part of the commercial assessment.

Four practical examples

The following examples are illustrative scenarios, not accounts of completed client matters.

Example 1: An excessively narrow sustainability criterion

A bidder identifies a discriminatory label requirement in the documents. It must not let the tender deadline pass unused. A complaint and possible correction are prepared. Raising the issue only after an adverse award outcome may be too late under statutory complaint requirements.

Example 2: Exclusion for a missing declaration

A contracting authority excludes a bid over an ESG declaration. Assessment covers the requirement, supplementation and equal treatment. Following rejection of the complaint, the application deadline is monitored. The commercial value of chamber proceedings also depends on the prospect of award.

Example 3: The review chamber rejects the application

A bidder considers an appeal. Filing and complete reasons are prepared within the two-week period. The current absence of suspensive effect is addressed simultaneously. An appeal must not be filed on the assumption that it automatically blocks award.

Example 4: The contract has already been awarded

A business learns later of an award without an ordinary notice. Scope, possible ineffectiveness and special deadlines are examined. Not every procurement error invalidates the contract. Damages may require different conditions and evidence.

Related topics

Contact

Your next step in ESG law.

Whether your matter concerns contracts, regulatory proceedings or a dispute, tell us what you need. We will clarify the legal issues and next steps with you.

horak Rechtsanwälte Partnerschaft mbB · Georgstraße 48 · 30159 Hannover