ESGrecht – horak Rechtsanwälte

Home / Proceedings & remedies

Proceedings & remedies

Labour courts, conciliation committees and employment appeals

Employee claims and workplace co-determination follow different procedural routes. We assess claims, order proceedings, conciliation committees, interim relief and the remedies available in each case.

Judgment proceedings for individual claims

Pay, compensation, dismissal protection and many other employment claims are handled through judgment proceedings. A claim needs specified relief and supporting facts. Dismissal challenges generally must observe the three-week period from receipt of written termination. Collective or contractual exclusion periods may additionally affect other claims.

Labour proceedings generally begin with a conciliation hearing. If no agreement is reached, further preparation and potentially a chamber hearing with evidence follow. Settlements may regulate payment, references, return to work, allocation of duties or termination. Wording and enforceability are decisive.

Order proceedings and conciliation committees

Works constitution disputes generally follow order proceedings. Participants and applications depend on the particular legal question. Judicial investigation does not remove the need to prepare the facts fully and coherently. ESG software, conduct policies and work organisation may raise central questions about co-determination rights.

The conciliation committee addresses specified workplace regulatory matters and is not a general appellate court. Jurisdiction, composition and subject must be established. Its award, limits on powers and judicial review follow separate rules. A dispute about whether a right exists may differ from one about how it is exercised.

Interim relief

Urgent individual or collective issues may require interim proceedings. Entitlement and urgency need sound substantiation. A provisional arrangement is not automatically permissible merely because a project is about to start. The court considers consequences for both sides and potential pre-emption of the main case.

Threatened unlawful data processing or disregard of participation rights may raise restraint and preservation issues. Main-proceeding deadlines remain separate. An interim application does not, for example, replace a timely dismissal protection claim.

Appeals and complaints

Labour Court judgments may be appealed under section 64 ArbGG. The filing period is generally one month and the reasoning period two months under section 66. An appeal on law to the Federal Labour Court generally requires leave. A complaint against refusal of leave has its own requirements.

In order proceedings, the remedies are a complaint to the Regional Labour Court and potentially a legal complaint to the Federal Labour Court. Interim proceedings have restrictions on further review. Hearing complaints and reinstatement are special, narrowly limited instruments. Correct terminology alone is insufficient: relief, reasoning and timing must all comply.

Costs and organisation

In first-instance labour judgment proceedings, a party generally cannot recover its own lawyer’s fees from the opponent, even if successful. This differs from ordinary civil litigation. Order proceedings and higher instances have separate cost rules. These distinctions are assessed commercially before litigation or settlement.

Four practical examples

The following examples are illustrative scenarios, not accounts of completed client matters.

Example 1: Dismissal after a report

An employee considers dismissal retaliatory. The dismissal challenge period is assessed independently of the internal investigation. The report, personnel decision and objective reasons are documented. Several legal bases may apply alongside one another.

Example 2: A works council challenges ESG software

New software analyses individual behaviour. Participation rights and technical functions are examined. Order proceedings, a conciliation committee or interim relief may be appropriate depending on the question. Signing the provider’s contract does not replace required participation.

Example 3: Compensation for discriminatory selection

An applicant asserts claims. Written assertion, filing deadlines and indicative facts are assessed. The employer preserves the actual selection records. An invented retrospective selection reason would not provide a sound factual or legal defence.

Example 4: The losing party wants further review

After judgment, appeal admissibility and possible grounds are examined. For an order, the appropriate complaint route must instead be identified. The different procedures must not be confused. Periods are calculated from the complete decision and service.

Related topics

Contact

Your next step in ESG law.

Whether your matter concerns contracts, regulatory proceedings or a dispute, tell us what you need. We will clarify the legal issues and next steps with you.

horak Rechtsanwälte Partnerschaft mbB · Georgstraße 48 · 30159 Hannover