ESGrecht – horak Rechtsanwälte

Home / Business & responsibility

Business & responsibility

Employment law, human rights and social standards

The social dimension of ESG concerns employment, occupational safety, employee participation and human rights. We connect operational requirements with supply chain duties and assist with employment disputes.

Own operations and supply chains

Employment duties apply within a business regardless of whether it must report on ESG. Working time, minimum pay, health protection and participation rights need assessment for the particular employment model. For external personnel, contractual terms and actual practice must be considered together. A sustainability policy replaces neither a lawful employment contract nor appropriate workplace protection.

Supply chains involve different legal systems and international standards. LkSG requirements must be distinguished from employment law directly applicable locally. Available influence and appropriate measures depend on the particular risk. A foreign audit report should not be accepted without review as evidence covering every human rights issue.

Work organisation and employee participation

New recording systems, training programmes, codes of conduct and ESG targets may trigger works council participation rights. Information, consultation or co-determination may be required depending on the measure. Early assessment is particularly important for technical systems monitoring behaviour or performance. A central group decision does not automatically remove local participation rights.

Works agreements can regulate data protection, responsibilities and permitted analyses. They must comply with statutory minimum standards. Internationally uniform policies should leave room for local requirements. Transition measures also require assessment of their effects on training, transfers, employment and potentially operational changes.

Complaints and investigations

Reports of exploitation, discrimination or occupational safety problems require appropriate investigation. Both reporting persons and those concerned need protection. Interviews, document review and data analysis require a legal basis. Allegations should not be presented as proven merely because they appear in a complaint.

Remedial measures should be verifiable, with responsibilities, deadlines, follow-up and appropriate communication. Employment sanctions require assessment of the right to be heard, proportionality and participation. Internal investigations do not automatically suspend dismissal, litigation or forfeiture deadlines.

Proceedings and remedies

Individual employment claims generally follow judgment proceedings before the labour courts; works constitution disputes usually follow the separate order procedure. Urgent injunction or participation issues may require interim proceedings. Appeals on fact and law, complaints, appeals on law and legal complaints have different conditions depending on the procedure. The conciliation committee is a separate instrument for certain workplace regulatory disputes.

Occupational safety orders, fines or criminal allegations involve other authorities and jurisdictions. Cross-border cases also require assessment of jurisdiction and applicable employment law. A choice of law cannot freely exclude mandatory employee protection.

Four practical examples

The following examples are illustrative scenarios, not accounts of completed client matters.

Example 1: ESG software records employee data

A business wants to analyse individual sustainability targets digitally. We assess purpose, data scope and participation rights. A data-minimising design and appropriate works agreement may be required. Calling a measure sustainable does not make performance monitoring lawful.

Example 2: Working time problems at a supplier

An audit reveals systematically excessive hours. Assessment connects local law with the customer’s relevant due diligence duties. A realistic remediation plan considers purchasing practices and delivery pressure. Termination is not mechanically treated as the only solution.

Example 3: Transforming a plant

A climate-related production change affects duties and staffing needs. Training, transfers and potential operational changes are assessed legally. The technical project plan is coordinated with participation procedures. An ESG target does not replace a necessary employment-law measure.

Example 4: Disadvantage following a complaint

After reporting safety deficiencies, an employee loses responsibilities. We examine the connection, protective provisions and decision records. Investigation of the original report and assessment of the personnel measure must be separate and fair. Imminent disadvantages may require prompt judicial protection.

Related topics

Contact

Your next step in ESG law.

Whether your matter concerns contracts, regulatory proceedings or a dispute, tell us what you need. We will clarify the legal issues and next steps with you.

horak Rechtsanwälte Partnerschaft mbB · Georgstraße 48 · 30159 Hannover