ESGrecht – horak Rechtsanwälte

Home / Proceedings & remedies

Proceedings & remedies

ESG funding, state aid, customs and fiscal court protection

Transition projects may qualify for funding while raising tax or customs issues. We assess grant conditions, recovery demands and the correct route for challenging official decisions.

Eligibility before the project starts

The programme, applicant, project commencement and eligible costs need early clarification. Ordering before approval or a permitted start may jeopardise funding. A political announcement does not create a secured payment entitlement. The award decision, guidelines and ancillary provisions define the actual position.

After approval, use of funds, evidence, change notifications and deadlines need organisation. Project alterations may require consent. Procurement law or special purchasing conditions may also bind private recipients. A commercially sensible replacement investment is not automatically harmless to funding.

State aid and recovery

Public support may fall under European state aid law. Exemptions, approved schemes and de minimis rules have different conditions. Businesses must correctly assess matters including cumulation, linked enterprises and applicable limits. A national grant decision does not always remove EU-law recovery risk.

Withdrawal, revocation or recovery requires assessment of legal basis, legitimate expectations, periods, discretion and EU requirements. Administrative funding litigation differs from civil disputes with project partners. EU decisions may additionally engage European judicial remedies.

Imports and energy matters require assessment of classification, origin, declarations and special relief. The remedy depends on the specific tax or sectoral decision. Not every climate-related payment belongs in fiscal court, and not every import measure is an ordinary customs assessment.

Import, use, measurement and supply chain records must be consistent. Incorrect statements can create fine or criminal risks alongside additional assessments. Technical evaluation of goods is often necessary for reliable legal classification. Parallel inspections require coordinated procedures.

Objection, litigation and interim protection

Within the Fiscal Code’s scope, an objection is generally considered against a challengeable administrative act; the period is normally one month. After the objection decision, Fiscal Court proceedings may be available. The objection alone generally does not suspend enforcement. Suspension or an interim order needs separate assessment.

Fiscal Court judgments generally have no ordinary appeal on fact and law. Appeals on law and refusal-of-leave complaints to the Federal Fiscal Court require statutory conditions. The Fiscal Court Code sets special periods and reasoning requirements. Ordinary grant decisions may instead fall within administrative jurisdiction. This distinction is checked before filing.

Four practical examples

The following examples are illustrative scenarios, not accounts of completed client matters.

Example 1: Equipment is ordered before approval

A business signs a supply contract and then applies for funding. Permitted project commencement and programme conditions are examined. A later assertion that the order was meant to be non-binding is insufficient without matching contractual terms. Funding status is clarified before further steps.

Example 2: Recovery because the project changed

Funded equipment differs from the application. We assess change notifications, approval scope and recovery basis. Depending on the law, a partial solution or fresh decision may be possible. Payment and challenge deadlines continue regardless of negotiations.

Example 3: Tariff classification changes obligations

An imported component is classified differently from expectations. Technical description and tariff rules are compared. Consequences for levies and other import duties require assessment. A contract with the foreign seller does not replace a correct declaration to the authority.

Example 4: An adverse assessment

A business disputes an additional charge. Objection and suspension applications are assessed separately. Without suspension, payment may remain due despite the pending objection. After its determination, the court filing period and fiscal jurisdiction are checked.

Related topics

Contact

Your next step in ESG law.

Whether your matter concerns contracts, regulatory proceedings or a dispute, tell us what you need. We will clarify the legal issues and next steps with you.

horak Rechtsanwälte Partnerschaft mbB · Georgstraße 48 · 30159 Hannover