ESGrecht – horak Rechtsanwälte

Home / Environment & transition

Environment & transition

ESG in real estate, buildings and construction

Sustainability requirements affect property acquisition, construction, financing and use. We assess public-law duties, contracts and liability relating to energy measures, contamination and sustainable building concepts.

Assessment covers use, permits, technical equipment, energy requirements and known environmental burdens. Protection of existing use, retrofit duties and requirements for alterations must be considered separately. An energy performance certificate does not describe every legal risk. Nor does certification replace a public-law permit.

European building rules, German building energy law and local planning may interact. For a particular project, the key question is which provision already applies and which national implementation requires separate review. Political targets and renovation recommendations are not equivalent to directly enforceable duties for every property.

Acquisition, construction and technical characteristics

Purchase agreements should address known risks, data room statements and warranted characteristics clearly. Contamination, asbestos, energy consumption and departures from permits can raise different liability issues. A general ESG clause cannot replace a specific description of the condition. The assessment’s scope and technical experts should match the commercial risk.

Construction contracts must translate sustainability targets into measurable work. Materials, energy values, certification, evidence and responsibility for interfaces need alignment. An obligation to achieve certification may extend beyond supplying specified materials. Acceptance, defect remedies and variations therefore remain central.

Green leases and operation

Commercial leases may address energy information, consumption reduction, waste arrangements or sustainable fit-out. Responsibilities, costs, data exchange and actual influence are decisive. A tenant cannot automatically warrant the energy performance of the entire building envelope. Conversely, a landlord needs reliable information for its own evidence requirements.

Alterations and operational measures must be compatible with contractual use, public permissions and safety requirements. Consumption data also raise privacy and trade secret issues. Residential leases are subject to additional mandatory protections; commercial models cannot simply be transferred unchanged.

Disputes and remedies

Construction and purchase defects may lead to rectification, price reduction, rescission or damages. Independent evidence proceedings can preserve the condition early. Regulatory prohibitions on use, remediation orders or permit refusals require assessment of the relevant administrative remedies. Urgent cases may additionally need separate interim proceedings.

Cost and timing consequences are evaluated alongside the desired remedy. A settlement may combine remediation, evidence, payment and future operation. It does not automatically bind authorities or third parties. Insurance coverage and public-law responsibility remain separate questions.

Four practical examples

The following examples are illustrative scenarios, not accounts of completed client matters.

Example 1: Acquisition with unknown contamination

After completion, an authority requires soil investigations. We assess public-law responsibility and the purchase agreement separately. Seller claims may exist but do not automatically prevent regulatory action against the buyer. Evidence preservation and deadlines are coordinated from the outset.

Example 2: Certification is missed

A new building fails to meet the contractually described standard. Assessment identifies who owed which result and which interface failed. Technical reports are combined with contract and acceptance records. Paying an additional certification fee alone would not remedy a substantive construction defect.

Example 3: Consumption data under a commercial lease

A landlord needs data for financing and reporting. Scope, purpose and frequency are agreed. The tenant also protects trade secrets and personal information. A clearly limited cooperation duty is often more robust than an undefined obligation of complete ESG transparency.

Example 4: Renovation during operations

An energy improvement interferes with a tenant’s production. Construction sequencing, duties to tolerate works, permits and potential compensation are examined. A coordinated supplementary agreement can regulate operating times, access and costs. The commercially desired measure must not bypass necessary public permissions.

Related topics

Contact

Your next step in ESG law.

Whether your matter concerns contracts, regulatory proceedings or a dispute, tell us what you need. We will clarify the legal issues and next steps with you.

horak Rechtsanwälte Partnerschaft mbB · Georgstraße 48 · 30159 Hannover