ESGrecht – horak Rechtsanwälte

Home / Supply chains & products

Supply chains & products

Greenwashing, environmental advertising and sustainability labels

Environmental claims influence purchasing decisions and create significant injunction and liability risks. We review claims, labelling and certification marks and assist with cease-and-desist demands, interim injunctions and proceedings on the merits.

The overall impression is decisive

An environmental claim may be conveyed through words, images, colours, symbols or a product name. The decisive issue is what the intended audience understands in context. Legal review therefore considers packaging, websites, shops, advertisements and explanatory information together. An internally accurate calculation does not protect advertising that creates a broader impression.

Statements about climate impact, recyclability, resource conservation or social production need an accurate reference point, scope and evidence. If only packaging is meant, the design should not suggest that the entire product is environmentally friendly. Comparisons need a verifiable basis. Technically accurate individual statements may become misleading when material limitations are omitted.

Stricter rules since 2026

The amendments to the German Act Against Unfair Competition (UWG) applicable since September 2026 contain specific requirements for generic environmental claims, sustainability labels and product climate claims based on emissions offsetting. The precise statement must be assessed against each prohibition. An additional footnote does not automatically cure a claim that is prohibited in itself.

Older goods require consideration of section 15b UWG. For certain goods placed on the market before 27 September 2026, it requires a differentiated assessment of enforcement in light of good faith and proportionality. This is not blanket permission to continue unchanged legacy advertising. Proposals for further European legislation must not be confused with existing law.

Review before publication

A claims dossier connects the specific advertisement with calculations, evidence, boundaries and validity periods. Reports and certificates must actually substantiate the advertised statement. Future objectives require review of credible planning, measurable intermediate steps and the applicable legal requirements. Distributors should receive approved versions and clear rules on changes.

A change in the product, evidence or law may require renewed approval. This also applies to translations: a narrowly framed German statement may be understood more broadly in another language. Trade marks and figurative signs are included in the assessment; registration does not confer immunity under unfair competition law.

Cease-and-desist demands, interim proceedings and appeals

Following a cease-and-desist demand, we examine standing, the particular advertisement, risk of repetition, deadline and requested undertaking. A contractual penalty extends beyond an individual advertising contact and should not be accepted without review. If interim proceedings are threatened, a protective brief may be useful, although it cannot guarantee that an injunction will be refused.

An injunction issued by order without an oral hearing can generally be opposed; the remedy against a judgment follows the Code of Civil Procedure. The order must be observed until effectively lifted or stayed. Proceedings on the merits address injunctive relief, costs and potentially other claims. Interim and main proceedings are separate, with their own costs and deadlines.

Four practical examples

The following examples are illustrative scenarios, not accounts of completed client matters.

Example 1: Offset-based product advertising

A product is advertised as climate neutral because certificates were purchased. In addition to evidence, the specific UWG prohibitions on such product claims require assessment. Merely linking to an offset project does not necessarily legitimise the statement. Lawful communication must respect its actual subject and statutory limits.

Example 2: An in-house sustainability label

A retailer designs a green emblem for its own product range. We examine whether it is understood as a sustainability label and what certification requirements apply. An invented certification mark cannot be substantiated merely by an internal quality policy. Design, wording and use are assessed together.

Example 3: A demand shortly before a trade fair

A competitor challenges brochures immediately before a trade fair. The exact advertising and evidence are first preserved. Defence, prompt adjustments and, where appropriate, a protective brief are then prepared. A rushed undertaking could cover additional campaigns and create substantial contractual penalty risks.

Example 4: Recyclable only under special conditions

Packaging is theoretically recyclable but rarely collected by the relevant waste system. Legal review considers consumers’ understanding and which practical conditions must be disclosed. Technical material properties and actually available recovery routes are documented separately.

Related topics

Contact

Your next step in ESG law.

Whether your matter concerns contracts, regulatory proceedings or a dispute, tell us what you need. We will clarify the legal issues and next steps with you.

horak Rechtsanwälte Partnerschaft mbB · Georgstraße 48 · 30159 Hannover