ESGrecht – horak Rechtsanwälte

Home / Insights / 2023

Reporting and strategy

ESRS in 2023: materiality and data quality before first reporting

The first European sustainability reporting standards made the practical CSRD framework more tangible. Businesses needed a transparent selection of topics and reliable data collection.

Archive allocation: 2023-07-31. Prepared retrospectively and legally reviewed on 15 November 2026. The archive date identifies the topic’s period, not an earlier publication. Historical developments and the current assessment are distinguished below.

Reporting and strategy · European reporting standards · CSRD reporting · ESG data

The European Commission adopted the first ESRS set on 31 July 2023. It covers environmental, social and governance topics and aims to standardise sustainability reporting. Whether a business must report depends on the applicable statutory scope, not on the standards alone.

Implementation and potential disputes

A materiality assessment needs clear criteria, documented evaluations and a suitable response to conflicting results. Financial risks and impacts on people or the environment are not identical. Excluding a topic from detailed treatment therefore calls for reasons just as including it does.

Data supplied by subsidiaries or supply chains benefit from common definitions, periods and responsibilities. Technical plausibility does not replace legal review of publication. Changes after approval require an assessment of related reports, advertising and customer communications. Original versions and calculation records support evidence if a statement is challenged.

Four practical examples

Illustrative scenarios, not accounts of completed client matters.

1. A topic is overlooked

A manufacturing company treats water use only as a cost. Its assessment also examines local impacts and records the evaluation.

2. A group receives inconsistent figures

Entities use different periods. Binding data definitions and traceable conversions prevent misleading comparisons.

3. An estimate appears to be measured

A supply chain figure rests on assumptions. The methodology and uncertainty are identified and approved internally.

4. A reporting figure enters advertising

Sales reuses an indicator without its qualification. The advertising claim receives a separate review of scope and potential misleading effect.

Position today

Later relief and changes, particularly the 2025 ESRS quick-fix and the 2026 reform, belong in every current assessment. The initial 2023 rules are not an immutable data catalogue.

Documents for review

The materiality matrix, evaluation records, data manual, calculation files, approvals and external statements support structured review.

Official sources

Related specialist guidance

Discuss your ESG matter

Tell us about your question or dispute. All enquiry fields are optional.