ESGrecht – horak Rechtsanwälte

Home / Insights / 2024

Case law and remedies

The BGH’s 2024 “climate neutral” ruling: explanations belong with the claim

Environmental advertising terms can carry several meanings. The Federal Court of Justice’s climate-neutrality judgment highlighted clear explanation within the advertising context.

Archive allocation: 2024-06-28. Prepared retrospectively and legally reviewed on 15 November 2026. The archive date identifies the topic’s period, not an earlier publication. Historical developments and the current assessment are distinguished below.

Case law and remedies · Green claims · Legal remedies · Climate law

On 27 June 2024, the Federal Court of Justice decided case I ZR 98/23 concerning “climate neutral” advertising. It stressed strict requirements of clarity and explanation for environmental claims. The distinction between avoiding emissions and offsetting them is particularly important to understanding the statement.

Implementation and potential disputes

Assessment starts with the actual advertisement rather than an isolated list of certificates. Product or company scope, presentation and visible explanation determine the overall impression. A link to a detailed information page does not automatically resolve every disclosure problem in the original advertisement.

Following a warning letter, versions, duration and distribution should be preserved. The injunction claim, urgency and scope of a possible undertaking require review. An overly broad promise may cover future advertising forms. Conversely, a cosmetic wording change may be insufficient if the misleading overall impression remains.

Four practical examples

Illustrative scenarios, not accounts of completed client matters.

1. A poster contains only a slogan

The climate explanation appears exclusively on another website. The company assesses which information is needed in the advertisement itself.

2. Certification covers only a site

The advertisement concerns a product. Certificate scope and claim are compared before the campaign continues.

3. An undertaking is drafted broadly

The draft also covers materially different statements. Its scope, contractual penalty and the specific alleged infringement require review.

4. A retailer adopts manufacturer wording

The retailer preserves evidence and assesses its own use. Identifying the source does not replace legal review of the advertising.

Position today

Stricter EmpCo implementing rules have applied since September 2026. The 2024 judgment remains relevant to misleading environmental advertising but is not the complete current legal test.

Documents for review

Original advertisements, dated screenshots, certificates, emissions calculations, explanations and warning letters are decisive.

Official sources

Related specialist guidance

Discuss your ESG matter

Tell us about your question or dispute. All enquiry fields are optional.