ESGrecht – horak Rechtsanwälte

Home / Supply chains & products

Supply chains & products

Supply chain law: LkSG and CSDDD

Supply chain law requires a reasoned, risk-based organisation. We assess scope, support risk analyses and remedial measures, and represent businesses in regulatory challenges and contractual disputes.

Distinguishing German legislation from the European directive

The German Supply Chain Due Diligence Act (LkSG) establishes specific human rights and certain environmental due diligence duties. Assessment starts with the entity, relevant employee figures and its own business operations. The extent and triggers of supplier-related duties differ. Not every small business is directly subject to the Act, even if customers demand extensive sustainability information.

The European CSDDD was amended by Directive (EU) 2026/470. The new framework provides, among other things, for substantially higher thresholds and later application. The Commission identifies 26 July 2028 for national implementing measures and generally 26 July 2029 for application; specific reporting rules concern later financial years. This does not automatically repeal the LkSG. German legislation and administrative enforcement practice must each be assessed separately.

Risk analysis, prevention and remediation

Risk analysis must reflect actual business relationships. Country and sector indicators provide a starting point but cannot replace assessment of specific information. An identified problem requires consideration of severity, likelihood, influence and the business’s own contribution. Measures should document responsibility, timing and effectiveness checks.

Contracts and audits are tools within this process. A supplier’s signed commitment does not remedy a known breach. Equally, immediate termination is not always required or appropriate. Prevention, remediation, cooperation and, where necessary, suspension or termination are assessed against statutory requirements and the circumstances.

Complaints procedures and documentation

A complaints mechanism must be accessible to affected groups and enable relevant concerns to be addressed. Responsibilities, confidentiality, protection against disadvantage and follow-up belong together. LkSG procedures and an internal reporting channel under the Whistleblower Protection Act have different scopes; a shared technical platform must properly accommodate both.

The discontinuation of certain administrative reporting reviews must be distinguished from statutory obligations. The enforcement relief announced in September 2025 does not mean that all due diligence or documentation duties disappear. Before a specific decision, we check the applicable legislation, administrative guidance and period.

Administrative proceedings and civil claims

An inspection requires assessment of competence, information requests, the right to be heard and potential measures. Administrative acts may be challenged through the relevant administrative remedies and, where appropriate, interim applications. An objection to an administrative fine under the Regulatory Offences Act (OWiG) is a separate matter. A substantive response does not replace a formal remedy.

Section 3(3) LkSG does not create an independent basis for civil liability; liability arising independently of the Act remains possible. Contract law, general tort law, foreign law and private international law may therefore still be relevant. Procedural standing to assert another’s rights and associations’ powers must be distinguished from the substantive cause of action.

Four practical examples

The following examples are illustrative scenarios, not accounts of completed client matters.

Example 1: Specific evidence of child labour

A buyer receives photographs from an upstream supplier’s plant. The information is preserved and checked for plausibility. A risk-based investigation and coordinated remedial steps follow. Merely referring to a supplier code would not be a complete response; affected persons’ protection and the reliability of the findings also need consideration.

Example 2: Audit access refused

A supplier refuses a contractually agreed inspection. We assess the audit clause’s scope, conditions and enforceability. Alternatives such as independent evidence or a limited audit are considered. Whether supply may be interrupted or the agreement terminated also depends on remediation periods, severity of risk and contractual wording.

Example 3: A BAFA hearing

An authority challenges the handling of a complaint. The business reconstructs receipt, assessment, decisions and measures. Its response explains the actual organisation and remediable deficiencies. If a binding order follows, its scope, proportionality and potential interim protection require separate assessment.

Example 4: A small supplier is asked to assume all duties

A large customer demands that a supplier take over its entire due diligence obligations. The supplier examines which specific cooperation duties can reasonably be agreed. Responsibilities, costs, influence and data scope are defined. The customer’s statutory responsibility cannot be outsourced through a blanket clause alone.

Related topics

Contact

Your next step in ESG law.

Whether your matter concerns contracts, regulatory proceedings or a dispute, tell us what you need. We will clarify the legal issues and next steps with you.

horak Rechtsanwälte Partnerschaft mbB · Georgstraße 48 · 30159 Hannover