ESGrecht – horak Rechtsanwälte

Home / Governance & international trade

Governance & international trade

ESG integrity: corruption, sanctions and internal investigations

Responsible governance includes corruption risks, sanctioned counterparties and internal suspicions. ESG reviews should connect these matters with procurement and sales without confusing distinct legal assessments.

Assess corruption and trade controls separately

Bribery risks may arise in private commerce and dealings with public officials. A payment labelled a consultancy fee or donation is assessed by its actual purpose. Intermediaries require transparent documentation of services, remuneration, recipients and commercial background.

Sanctions and export controls take a different approach. Depending on the transaction, persons, ownership and control, goods, destination, use and indirect provision must be checked. An unremarkable sustainability questionnaire does not replace sanctions screening; a single name search does not suffice in every case. Current law at the transaction and, where relevant, during performance is decisive.

Organisation and contracts

We assess approvals, responsibilities and escalation. Intermediary contracts should specify services, permitted payments, evidence and inspection rights. General compliance clauses must correspond to actual performance. Suspicions require assessment of whether payments or deliveries must be suspended and which notifications are necessary or permitted.

An effective framework also covers donations, sponsorship, gifts, conflicts and beneficial owners. Controls should reflect risk and be documented coherently. Excessive data collection may itself create privacy or employment issues. International matters require appropriate foreign-law advice where necessary.

Investigations and defence

Reports trigger preservation of documents and electronic evidence, separation of responsibilities and conflicts checks. Internal interviews require employment and privacy preparation. Confidentiality, professional secrecy and potential seizure must be assessed for the specific engagement and procedure; a blanket guarantee that all internal documents are protected would be incorrect.

Regulatory investigation, fine proceedings, individual criminal defence and corporate representation may involve different interests. National administrative measures, criminal procedural interventions and EU listing acts have distinct remedies. Competence, standing and deadlines are assessed against the act concerned. Termination, recovery and officer liability claims may also arise. Our pages on fine and criminal proceedings and EU remedies explain the distinctions.

Four practical examples

The following examples are illustrative scenarios, not accounts of completed client matters.

Example 1: An unusual intermediary commission

An intermediary demands a high success fee paid to a third-party account. Services, recipient and links to the customer are examined before payment. The assessment is documented; an attractive contract does not replace clarification of specific warning signs.

Example 2: A supplier has a new owner

Ownership changes during a long-term agreement. The business examines whether a sanctions prohibition or authorisation duty arises. Performance obligations and permitted payment channels are reassessed accordingly.

Example 3: Alleged manipulation of ESG audits

An internal report alleges that a verifier was paid for a favourable result. Evidence, engagement and payment flows are preserved. The business also investigates the reliability of published statements and necessary corrections.

Example 4: Several participants are investigated

Management and employees receive official correspondence. Assessment identifies accused persons and divergent interests. Corporate representation and individual defence are separated where necessary; deadlines and information rights are handled individually.

Related topics

Contact

Your next step in ESG law.

Whether your matter concerns contracts, regulatory proceedings or a dispute, tell us what you need. We will clarify the legal issues and next steps with you.

horak Rechtsanwälte Partnerschaft mbB · Georgstraße 48 · 30159 Hannover