ESGrecht – horak Rechtsanwälte

Home / Competition & governance

Competition & governance

Sustainability cooperation and competition law

Shared sustainability standards, take-back systems and purchasing initiatives may save resources. When competitors cooperate, however, permitted coordination, information exchange and third-party access must be clarified.

Sustainability does not remove the cartel prohibition

Article 101 TFEU and German competition law also apply to environmental or social objectives. The Commission’s Horizontal Guidelines include a dedicated chapter on sustainability agreements. Cooperation without relevant restrictions differs from joint price, quantity or market-sharing arrangements. Restrictive agreements require an exemption assessment against statutory conditions; a general public-interest reference is insufficient.

Transparency, voluntary participation, non-discriminatory access and remaining competition may be particularly important for sustainability standards. Whether a project falls within the assessment framework depends on its actual design. Individual guideline terms should not be treated as blanket approval.

Organising cooperation in practice

We assess objectives, participants, markets and the necessary degree of cooperation. Governance, admission, fees, intellectual property and exit are then regulated. Information exchange should remain limited to what is needed. Shared platforms require access, aggregation and confidentiality arrangements; sensitive price and customer data must not casually enter project discussions.

Joint purchasing requires particular attention to bargaining power, supplier effects and possible exclusion. Rejecting a supplier on an ESG criterion also needs independent assessment. Professional and industry associations benefit from clear agendas, minutes and escalation rules. A compliance reminder at the start of a meeting does not cure an unlawful agreement.

Regulatory proceedings and judicial protection

Suitable novel questions may justify seeking informal guidance from the competent competition authority before implementation. This does not automatically replace the undertaking’s own assessment. Information requests, searches or cessation orders require immediate coordination of procedural rights, deadlines and evidence preservation.

The route depends on authority and measure. Commission decisions may be challenged before the General Court under statutory conditions. German competition authorities follow the GWB’s special appeal routes, not automatically ordinary administrative procedure. Civil injunction and damages claims may also arise. European remedies and fine defence therefore need coordination with the contractual strategy.

Four practical examples

The following examples are illustrative scenarios, not accounts of completed client matters.

Example 1: A shared recycling standard

Manufacturers develop a common take-back system. Assessment covers participation, fees and access for newcomers. Technical minimum requirements are separated from sales-price coordination, and the system receives confidentiality rules.

Example 2: An association sustainability surcharge

An association wants to recommend a uniform surcharge. Despite its environmental purpose, coordination may breach competition law. Advice instead examines permissible non-price initiatives and how members can calculate independently.

Example 3: Joint supplier assessment

Competitors want to pool audits. Limited exchange of objective findings is separated from prices, quantities and purchasing strategies. Access, privacy, trade secrets and independent supplier decisions are protected contractually.

Example 4: Exclusion from an industry initiative

A business is denied a label important for market access. Criteria, decision-making and competitive effects are assessed. Depending on the circumstances, internal review, regulatory involvement or civil interim relief may be appropriate.

Related topics

Contact

Your next step in ESG law.

Whether your matter concerns contracts, regulatory proceedings or a dispute, tell us what you need. We will clarify the legal issues and next steps with you.

horak Rechtsanwälte Partnerschaft mbB · Georgstraße 48 · 30159 Hannover