ESGrecht – horak Rechtsanwälte

Home / Climate & transactions

Climate & transactions

Carbon credits, carbon removal and voluntary carbon markets

Buying carbon credits involves more than a price per tonne. The promised climate effect, legal allocation, registry, transferability and consequences of later reversal are decisive.

Credits, emissions allowances and climate contributions

Voluntary credits differ from allowances in mandatory emissions trading systems. A voluntary credit does not automatically fulfil a statutory surrender obligation. Retiring a credit does not permit every environmental claim either. Contract review must therefore start with intended use: project financing, voluntary contribution, internal accounting or customer communications.

Regulation (EU) 2024/3012 establishes a voluntary European certification framework for permanent carbon removals, carbon farming and storage in products. Specific methodologies, verification requirements and recognised schemes need assessment for each project. Falling within the framework neither automatically approves every existing credit nor provides unrestricted permission for offset advertising.

What the agreement should cover

A reliable agreement describes the project, methodology, period, quantities and quality requirements. Verification, registry account, delivery, retirement and evidence must align. Double counting, lack of additionality, reversal, standard changes and participant insolvency require treatment. Liability provisions and replacement delivery must be practically enforceable.

Long-term offtake raises further questions: what quantity is guaranteed, what happens if permits or certification are delayed, and may the buyer withdraw if units cannot serve their intended purpose? Developers need to consider land rights, duration, monitoring and subsequent owners’ obligations. Financial regulation and tax consequences are assessed separately for products structured accordingly.

Disputes, evidence and remedies

Non-delivery or doubtful quality requires review of specifications, promised characteristics and the evidence chain. Performance, cure, unwinding and damages may be available under the agreement and applicable law. Registry data, verification reports and communications should be preserved early. Arbitration clauses may change the forum and affect costs and enforcement.

If advertising is challenged, defence against injunctive claims must be separate from the dispute with the credit provider. Pending recourse does not prevent an interim injunction. Our pages on civil litigation, arbitration and greenwashing explain the instruments.

Four practical examples

The following examples are illustrative scenarios, not accounts of completed client matters.

Example 1: A forest fire after purchase

A business buys credits from a forestry project; fire later destroys part of the storage. The agreement is reviewed for risk allocation, buffer reserves, replacement and notification duties. Published claims must also be assessed for necessary changes.

Example 2: Credits are offered twice

A buyer discovers contradictory registry entries. It preserves unit identifiers, account statements and seller assurances. Before further payments, assessment considers blocking delivery or retirement and securing claims through interim relief.

Example 3: A long-term carbon removal agreement

An industrial business finances future removals. Payments are linked to measurable milestones and independent verification. Clear consequences address failed certification, volume shortfalls and later rule changes.

Example 4: A climate-neutral product through offsets

A provider wants packaging to highlight voluntary credit purchases. The claim, audience and applicable unfair competition prohibitions are assessed. Even high-quality credits cannot legitimise a legally prohibited product neutrality claim.

Related topics

Contact

Your next step in ESG law.

Whether your matter concerns contracts, regulatory proceedings or a dispute, tell us what you need. We will clarify the legal issues and next steps with you.

horak Rechtsanwälte Partnerschaft mbB · Georgstraße 48 · 30159 Hannover