Proceedings & remedies
Mediation, conciliation and ESG arbitration
Not every ESG conflict needs a state court judgment. We assess negotiation, mediation, conciliation and arbitration and develop workable, verifiable solutions for domestic and international business relationships.
Choosing the right instrument
Negotiation allows parties to agree directly. In mediation, an independent person helps them reach their own solution without deciding the dispute. Conciliation may involve a proposed solution under the agreed rules. An arbitral tribunal, by contrast, generally makes a binding decision under a valid arbitration agreement.
The choice depends on urgency, evidence, confidentiality, the number of participants and later enforcement. An ongoing supply relationship may benefit from staged escalation. Threatened loss of evidence or short statutory deadlines nevertheless requires consideration of court protection. Starting discussions does not automatically stop time limits.
Mediation with clear arrangements
A mediation agreement should address scope, participants, confidentiality, costs and existing proceedings. Company representatives need adequate authority. Technical experts may help narrow disputed facts. The process is voluntary; a party cannot be compelled to accept a particular substantive settlement.
A solution may contain measures beyond what a judgment alone would deliver: joint audits, new data processes, remediation plans or amended supply terms. Mandatory law and third-party rights remain applicable. A private settlement cannot replace an administrative permit or legally required notification.
Arbitration clauses and procedure
An arbitration agreement must be valid and cover the particular dispute. Seat, institutional rules, language, number of arbitrators and applicable law influence proceedings. Unclear combinations of rules can create jurisdiction disputes. Not every public-law ESG dispute is arbitrable.
Proceedings generally involve a request, response, tribunal constitution, written submissions, evidence and an award. Confidentiality depends on the agreement, rules and legal system; it is not universally automatic or comprehensive. Expert evidence, document production and remote hearings are organised through procedural directions.
Interim measures and review
State courts may grant interim protection despite an arbitration agreement where statutory conditions are satisfied. Institutional emergency arbitrators or the tribunal may also order measures. Their scope and enforceability differ. Where several countries are involved, the location of assets and evidence should be assessed before applying.
An arbitral award generally has no ordinary appeal comparable to a court judgment. Setting aside and recognition review are confined to statutory grounds, such as specified procedural defects or public policy violations. A domestic setting-aside application generally must observe the three-month period under section 1059 ZPO. International enforcement is governed, among other instruments, by the New York Convention.
Four practical examples
The following examples are illustrative scenarios, not accounts of completed client matters.
Example 1: Preserving a supply relationship
An audit creates a dispute over working conditions and delivery periods. The parties agree to mediation with technical input. A settlement may specify remediation, follow-up and costs. Measures must be verifiable so that new interpretation disputes do not undermine the agreement.
Example 2: An international emissions data dispute
Two businesses have agreed an institutional arbitration clause. Jurisdiction, governing law and access to evidence are assessed. The procedure is structured around precise data and expert questions. A blanket confidentiality assertion should not defeat every necessary evidential step.
Example 3: Urgent access to documents
A contractual partner threatens to delete decisive documents. State court interim relief is considered despite arbitration. The application must establish a specific entitlement and urgency. Institutional emergency measures are examined in parallel for additional options.
Example 4: Enforcing an award abroad
The losing party does not pay. The award, service, agreement and asset position are prepared for recognition. A foreign court does not automatically retry the entire dispute. Formal errors and recognition obstacles may nevertheless complicate enforcement.
Further reading and legal sources
Legal position: 15 November 2026. General information does not replace an assessment of the individual case. Deadlines, transitional provisions, admissibility and representation requirements must be checked against the particular decision and procedural circumstances.
Related topics
Contact
Your next step in ESG law.
Whether your matter concerns contracts, regulatory proceedings or a dispute, tell us what you need. We will clarify the legal issues and next steps with you.
horak Rechtsanwälte Partnerschaft mbB · Georgstraße 48 · 30159 Hannover
