ESGrecht – horak Rechtsanwälte

Home / Business & responsibility

Business & responsibility

ESG due diligence in acquisitions and investments

ESG risks can materially affect price, liability and integration costs. We structure legal due diligence and translate its findings into specific provisions in acquisition agreements.

Assessment based on business model and risk

The scope of ESG due diligence reflects activities, locations, products, supply chains and transaction structure. A software company has different priorities from a chemical or logistics business. Assessment covers legal duties and commitments actually made. Public sustainability statements may be as important as permits and contracts.

Relevant matters include environmental and installation risks, occupational safety, supply chain organisation, reporting, product conformity, internal reports and pending proceedings. Document review and interviews are coordinated with technical or financial assessments. Legal due diligence does not replace soil testing or technical emissions measurement.

Data rooms and reliable findings

A report should distinguish confirmed findings, missing information and mere suspicions. Incomplete evidence is not automatically a breach, but may justify a closing condition or further review. Materiality depends on legal consequences, likelihood and commercial significance. A long list of general sustainability questions is of little use if core operating permits remain unchecked.

Access to confidential investigations, employee information and trade secrets is restricted. Clean-team arrangements may be necessary between competitors. Buyers and sellers cannot freely exchange personal information in a data room. Confidentiality protection must work with a meaningful risk assessment.

Translating findings into agreements

Depending on the findings, specific warranties, indemnities, price adjustments, closing conditions or pre-closing measures may be appropriate. An indemnity for identified contamination differs from a general warranty of lawful operation. Liability caps, periods, knowledge provisions and third-party claim procedures must fit together.

Outstanding permitting or remediation matters require identification of who will do what and by when. Insurance can cover particular risks but often treats known circumstances through specific inclusions or exclusions. The agreement should specify which documents count as disclosed and which statements are thereby qualified.

Integration and later disputes

After closing, responsibilities, policies and information systems need integration. The acquisition agreement cannot replace this work. New group membership may change reporting scope or contractual requirements. A concrete action plan with allocated responsibilities prevents identified risks from disappearing in daily business.

Later claims depend on notice and exclusion periods, evidence and agreed dispute resolution. Public remediation duties and private recourse often run in parallel. A buyer–seller settlement generally does not bind an authority without an appropriate legal basis.

Four practical examples

The following examples are illustrative scenarios, not accounts of completed client matters.

Example 1: A missing operating permit

The data room contains only an older permit despite expanded production. Actual technical conditions are compared with the decisions. Regulatory clarification or a closing condition may be necessary. A blanket seller warranty alone does not remove the risk of an operating prohibition.

Example 2: An undisclosed supply chain complaint

A significant allegation emerges after signing. The parties examine information duties, disclosure and potential closing obstacles. Investigation proceeds without prejudgment. Contractual rights are assessed against the actual findings and agreed risk allocation.

Example 3: A high ESG rating without evidence

A seller promotes a strong rating but cannot substantiate key data. Assessment separates rating methodology from specific statutory duties. Price-sensitive assumptions are secured through reliable evidence or targeted contractual provisions. A rating does not replace legal due diligence.

Example 4: Remediation costs after closing

Contamination causes higher costs than anticipated. We assess warranties, indemnities, cooperation and claim notification. Technical allocation of damage and legal deadlines must be coordinated. A premature remediation settlement may prejudice recourse where the contract requires seller participation.

Related topics

Contact

Your next step in ESG law.

Whether your matter concerns contracts, regulatory proceedings or a dispute, tell us what you need. We will clarify the legal issues and next steps with you.

horak Rechtsanwälte Partnerschaft mbB · Georgstraße 48 · 30159 Hannover