Strategy & reporting
Sustainable finance and green financing
Sustainability characteristics in financing must be legally clear and verifiable. We assist with loan terms, disclosures, ESG representations and disputes over metrics, information duties and liability.
Distinguishing financing from financial products
A corporate loan structured around sustainability is not the same as a regulated financial product with specific disclosures. The framework and duties depend on participants, product and distribution. SFDR, the Taxonomy, sector-specific supervision and general contract law may apply alongside one another. Terms such as “green” and “sustainable” require definition.
The disclosure framework under Articles 8 and 9 SFDR differs from a general state quality label. Disclosure status does not replace assessment of the investment or an accurate explanation of risks. The Taxonomy also assesses particular activities against its own criteria. These systems should not be treated as interchangeable in contracts and marketing.
Loan clauses and sustainability metrics
In sustainability-linked loans, metrics often influence interest or other contractual consequences. Targets, baselines, calculation, verification and adjustment mechanisms must be clear. Data errors, acquisitions, disposals and subsequent changes in law need treatment. A purely quantitative target may lose its commercial meaning without defined boundaries.
For use-of-proceeds green financing, the application of funds is additionally decisive. Eligible projects, evidence and consequences of diversion are agreed. Voluntary market standards may help but are not automatically law. Their incorporation and the precise scope of external assessments therefore matter.
Information, distribution and liability
Sustainability statements must match actual characteristics and prescribed documents. Brief marketing copy must not conceal material limitations. Investor information, advice and distribution are subject to the relevant protective duties. Our firm examines legal questions; economic evaluation and individual investment decisions are separate matters.
Incorrect information may engage different causes of action. Role, document, duty, causation and loss are decisive. A later deterioration in a sustainability metric does not necessarily prove that an earlier statement was false. Documented assumptions and accurate explanations of uncertainty can be significant.
Supervision, civil litigation and remedies
Regulatory objections require assessment of the specific measure and prescribed remedies. Disputes over interest adjustments, termination or evidence duties are civil matters. Capital market information may engage special collective procedural instruments, whose conditions require separate review.
A complaint to a supervisor does not automatically create an individual payment claim or suspend its limitation period. Conversely, a private settlement does not necessarily conclude public-law proceedings. Both levels need consideration in the strategy.
Four practical examples
The following examples are illustrative scenarios, not accounts of completed client matters.
Example 1: An interest increase after a missed ESG target
A lender raises interest even though an acquisition has made the metric incomparable. We review contractual adjustment rules and calculation. A transparent redefinition of boundaries may be negotiated. Without a contractual basis, the agreed target cannot simply be changed retrospectively.
Example 2: Green funds are used differently
A project fails and financing is temporarily used elsewhere. Permitted alternative use, information duties and possible cure periods are examined. The commercial merits of the replacement investment are insufficient if the contract imposes a narrower purpose restriction.
Example 3: Marketing contradicts disclosure
A product page promises comprehensive sustainability effects while contractual documents contain substantial limitations. Communications are reviewed as a whole for consistency. Legal assessment considers the audience’s actual understanding and applicable supervisory rules.
Example 4: Verification with a limited scope
A business relies on external confirmation, but the verifier examined only selected data points. We identify what was actually confirmed and what responsibility remains with the business. Contractual warranties and public statements are matched to the substantiated scope.
Further reading and legal sources
Taxonomy · Reporting · Civil appeals. SFDR – Regulation (EU) 2019/2088 · European Commission: Taxonomy.
Legal position: 15 November 2026. General information does not replace an assessment of the individual case. Deadlines, transitional provisions, admissibility and representation requirements must be checked against the particular decision and procedural circumstances.
Related topics
Contact
Your next step in ESG law.
Whether your matter concerns contracts, regulatory proceedings or a dispute, tell us what you need. We will clarify the legal issues and next steps with you.
horak Rechtsanwälte Partnerschaft mbB · Georgstraße 48 · 30159 Hannover
