Business & responsibility
Equal treatment, diversity and non-discriminatory processes
Diversity policies must comply with equal treatment law. We review HR processes, complaints arrangements and communications and assist in defending or resolving specific allegations of discrimination.
Legal limits on unequal treatment
The General Equal Treatment Act (AGG) protects against disadvantage on the grounds specified by law. In employment, it covers recruitment, advancement, remuneration, working conditions and termination, among other matters. Direct and indirect discrimination must be distinguished. An apparently neutral rule may particularly disadvantage certain groups and therefore require legal justification.
Not every difference in treatment is unlawful. Statutory exceptions, occupational requirements and permitted positive action must be assessed against their conditions. General references to customer preferences or corporate culture are insufficient. Equally, an ESG objective does not provide unrestricted authority to select candidates by protected characteristics.
HR processes and evidence
Job advertisements, selection criteria, interview guides and promotion decisions are reviewed for a consistent standard. Actual implementation matters as well as written policy. Documented objective criteria help explain decisions. Excessive collection of sensitive characteristic data can, however, create additional privacy risks.
Pay and development opportunities require examination of comparable work, evaluation methods and substantiated reasons for differentiation. Collective agreements and workplace rules must be considered. New European transparency requirements and national implementation require separate assessment; a directive should not generally be equated with immediately applicable employer duties.
Complaints procedures and remediation
A designated complaints body must receive and properly investigate reports. Affected persons, witnesses and accused individuals require fair treatment. Documentation, hearings, confidentiality and proportionate follow-up measures need coordination. AGG requirements differ from those of the Whistleblower Protection Act, even if a case engages both.
Training and prevention are important but do not automatically remedy a specific breach. Conversely, an allegation is not itself proof. We assist with structured investigations and measures that respect protective duties and participants’ rights. Sensitive findings are shared only with those who need them.
Claims, deadlines and proceedings
Employment claims may include compensation for non-material harm and damages. Section 15(4) AGG generally provides a two-month period for asserting claims in writing; its commencement and exceptions require case-specific assessment. Compensation litigation must also comply with section 61b ArbGG. An internal complaint does not necessarily replace the required assertion of a claim.
The burden-of-proof rule in section 22 AGG may become important where indicative facts are established. Timely, truthful decision records are therefore valuable. Labour court proceedings, appeals on fact and law and potentially appeals on law follow their own admissibility rules. Civil mass-market transactions have separate claim conditions and deadlines.
Four practical examples
The following examples are illustrative scenarios, not accounts of completed client matters.
Example 1: An age-related job advertisement
An advertisement expressly seeks a “young team member”. An unsuccessful applicant claims compensation. We review the advertisement, selection process and objective criteria. Later amendment of the advertisement does not remove a claim that may already have arisen. Future requirements are drafted more precisely and without discrimination.
Example 2: A diversity target for promotions
A business wants to support an underrepresented group. Legal assessment distinguishes permissible support measures from unlawful blanket selection decisions. Criteria, procedure and documentation are coordinated. A well-intentioned objective must be implemented within statutory limits.
Example 3: A harassment complaint
An employee reports repeated degrading remarks. A structured investigation secures information and protects participants against prejudgment. Appropriate interim measures are assessed. Depending on the findings, organisational or employment measures may follow; the complaint must not lead to unlawful disadvantage.
Example 4: Different remuneration
Employees challenge different salaries for similar work. Job profiles, responsibility and applied criteria are analysed. Objective distinctions are separated from discriminatory effects. A settlement may include adjustments and more transparent procedures without unlawfully disclosing personal salary information throughout the workforce.
Further reading and legal sources
Legal position: 15 November 2026. General information does not replace an assessment of the individual case. Deadlines, transitional provisions, admissibility and representation requirements must be checked against the particular decision and procedural circumstances.
Related topics
Contact
Your next step in ESG law.
Whether your matter concerns contracts, regulatory proceedings or a dispute, tell us what you need. We will clarify the legal issues and next steps with you.
horak Rechtsanwälte Partnerschaft mbB · Georgstraße 48 · 30159 Hannover
