ESGrecht – horak Rechtsanwälte

Home / Business & responsibility

Business & responsibility

Sustainable public procurement and procurement law

Sustainability criteria can shape public purchasing. We assist with lawful tender documents, sound bids and preservation of remedies before the contract is awarded.

Putting sustainability requirements in the right place

Technical specifications, selection criteria, award criteria and performance conditions have different functions. Environmental and social requirements must be placed appropriately and satisfy statutory conditions. A link to the subject matter, transparency and equal treatment are central tests. A generally desirable corporate policy should not become a barrier to competition without a relevant connection to the procurement.

Life-cycle costs, energy use, repairability or social requirements may be appropriate depending on the contract. Tender documents must show how criteria are assessed and weighted. Evidence and labels are subject to applicable rules, including acceptance of equivalent proof. A particular label should not be used mechanically to exclude competition.

Requirements for contracting authorities

We examine the connection between the need, specification and evaluation method. Criteria should be verifiable as well as ambitious. Contract performance needs evidence, inspection rights and proportionate responses to deviations. A commitment that earns points in the tender should not become meaningless in the resulting contract.

Documentation and bidder communications are part of legal certainty. Amendments, responses to bidder questions and extensions must respect equal treatment. Conflicts of interest and confidential information need organisational safeguards. Later contract modifications may also require a fresh procurement assessment.

Requirements for bidders

Bidders should review recognisable ambiguities and infringements early. A reservation in a bid may lead to exclusion rather than solve the problem. Commitments on supply chains, staff or carbon figures must match the actual delivery model. Subcontractors and proposed products therefore need consideration before submission.

An exclusion or adverse award decision requires the procurement file, stated reasons and the bidder’s submitted version. A complaint to the authority and an application for review are separate steps. A complaint alone does not provide the same award protection as a timely served review application. Standstill periods and exceptions need separate checking.

Review and appeals

Above the relevant EU thresholds, primary protection generally proceeds before a procurement review chamber, followed by an immediate appeal to the competent Higher Regional Court. Standing, complaint requirements and short deadlines are decisive. Below the thresholds, jurisdiction and instruments vary by state law and circumstances; the GWB review procedure cannot simply be transposed.

After a valid award, opportunities to challenge the contract are significantly restricted. The special ineffectiveness rules and deadlines in section 135 GWB require assessment. Damages claims may also be relevant. Further details are provided on our procurement review page.

Four practical examples

The following examples are illustrative scenarios, not accounts of completed client matters.

Example 1: A tender requires one label only

A contracting authority specifies one environmental label without considering equivalent evidence. A bidder examines the requirements and, where appropriate, complains in time. The authority may clarify or correct the documents. The decisive issues are the substantive characteristics to be proved and the lawfulness of the particular requirement.

Example 2: Unclear life-cycle costs

Evaluation includes maintenance and energy but does not disclose a sufficiently transparent calculation. Assessment covers transparency, comparability and effects on bids. A later change favouring only particular bidders would be problematic. Necessary clarifications must be introduced without discrimination.

Example 3: Exclusion over a supply chain declaration

A bid is excluded for a missing declaration. We examine the document required, possible supplementation and equal treatment. A review application may be necessary before award. A later damages action often does not provide an economically equivalent substitute for timely primary protection.

Example 4: A sustainability promise is abandoned after award

A contractor wants to replace an environmentally friendly material that was scored in the tender. The parties must assess procurement modification limits and contractual claims. A substantial change cannot simply be treated as a technical adjustment. Evidence, remediation and possible sanctions are coordinated under the contract.

Related topics

Contact

Your next step in ESG law.

Whether your matter concerns contracts, regulatory proceedings or a dispute, tell us what you need. We will clarify the legal issues and next steps with you.

horak Rechtsanwälte Partnerschaft mbB · Georgstraße 48 · 30159 Hannover