Environment & transition
Resources, waste, packaging and deforestation-free supply chains
The legal classification of raw materials and waste affects procurement, production, sales and disposal. We assess circular business models, take-back systems and origin evidence for businesses across the value chain.
Product, by-product or waste?
Whether a substance is a product, by-product or waste depends on statutory criteria and actual handling. Positive economic value or a sale price does not automatically exclude waste status. Nor does an internal label alone turn waste back into a product. Treatment, transport and use may each be subject to specific requirements.
A circular economy strategy must therefore consider the entire chain: generation, collection, processing, quality, transport and reuse. Cross-border shipments bring additional rules. Contractual clauses cannot freely remove public-law responsibility, but can allocate tasks, evidence and recourse internally.
Packaging and producer responsibility
Packaging, batteries and electrical equipment have different producer responsibility systems. Manufacturer or first-placer status must be assessed separately for each framework. Registration, participation, take-back and information duties are matched to distribution channels and countries. Marketplace sales or fulfilment arrangements do not automatically remove responsibility.
New European legislation has its own application and transitional dates. A regulation may already be in force while particular technical obligations apply later. We therefore examine the specific provision, product group and timing, not just the title of the legislation. Sustainability advertising is additionally assessed against the actual collection and recovery arrangements.
Origin, biodiversity and EUDR
For commodities and products associated with deforestation, the goods covered, operator role, origin and applicable starting dates need assessment. The EUDR is distinct from general supply chain duties. Geolocation, legality of production, risk assessment and due diligence statements may each have independent significance depending on the role and current rules.
Certification may support fact-finding but cannot automatically replace every statutory requirement. Unclear origins, mixed batches and conflicting information must be addressed transparently. Trade secrets and personal data require protection when information is shared with business partners and authorities. Applicable exemptions and simplifications are assessed by product.
Proceedings, orders and recourse
Depending on the legislation, authorities may require information, evidence, take-back, cessation or other remedial measures. A hearing, file access and technical clarification underpin an appropriate response. Binding decisions require identification of the competent appeal body and possible interim relief. Transported goods may additionally trigger customs or shipment procedures.
Businesses may dispute material quality, disposal costs, missing origin evidence or contractual guarantees. We examine who promised which characteristic and what evidence is available. Statements in parallel administrative and civil proceedings must be coordinated so that technical information and legal positions remain consistent.
Four practical examples
The following examples are illustrative scenarios, not accounts of completed client matters.
Example 1: Production residue as a raw material
A business sells residue to another manufacturer. Legal assessment addresses waste status, treatment and end-of-waste conditions. The offtake agreement and technical specification are adapted accordingly. Simply changing the product name would not remove existing disposal or transport duties.
Example 2: Packaging sales in several countries
An online retailer supplies customers directly in several EU countries. We determine its role and country-specific duties. Service providers and registrations are brought together in a responsibility plan. A German registration does not automatically suffice for every foreign market.
Example 3: Unclear timber origin
A shipment lacks reliable origin information. The importer assesses the goods covered, current EUDR applicability and required evidence. Release for supply and contractual recourse are considered separately. A claim against the seller does not automatically permit placing goods on the market despite public-law obstacles.
Example 4: A waste contractor fails
A contractor no longer performs its duties. The client identifies its remaining responsibility and necessary replacement measures. Evidence and transfer documents are preserved. Damages and insurance issues are pursued without delaying necessary protective or disposal measures.
Further reading and legal sources
Product law · Supply contracts · Environmental liability. EUDR – Regulation (EU) 2023/1115 · German Circular Economy Act · Packaging Act.
Legal position: 15 November 2026. General information does not replace an assessment of the individual case. Deadlines, transitional provisions, admissibility and representation requirements must be checked against the particular decision and procedural circumstances.
Related topics
Contact
Your next step in ESG law.
Whether your matter concerns contracts, regulatory proceedings or a dispute, tell us what you need. We will clarify the legal issues and next steps with you.
horak Rechtsanwälte Partnerschaft mbB · Georgstraße 48 · 30159 Hannover
