ESGrecht – horak Rechtsanwälte

Home / Environment & transition

Environment & transition

Climate law, energy, emissions trading and CBAM

Climate-related requirements affect installations, supply chains, investments and contracts. We assess emissions obligations, support energy projects and assist with regulatory decisions and commercial disputes.

Different regulatory systems

European and national emissions trading, carbon border adjustment, energy contracts and public installation law use different regulatory approaches. An emissions report does not simultaneously satisfy every evidence requirement imposed by a bank or customer. The operator, importer, product, activity and accounting period must first be identified. Competence and the appropriate court then follow from the relevant legislation.

CBAM requires particular attention to covered goods, tariff classification, import structures, emissions data and current exemptions and transitional provisions. The definitive phase starting in 2026 differs from the earlier reporting phase. Individual obligations may have different fulfilment dates. Outdated timetables or assumptions from the transitional period should therefore not simply be reused.

Preparing transition projects

A new energy supply or production process may raise permitting, grid, funding and contractual issues. Project planning must connect these procedures with technical lead times and financing. Planning permission, for example, does not automatically replace an assessment under immission control law or a necessary grid connection agreement.

Power purchase agreements, energy supply and heating concepts require rules on price, delivery profile, interruption, guarantees of origin and changes in law. Purchasing a guarantee of origin cannot simply be equated with any desired claim about a product’s overall climate impact. Supply agreements and public communications need separate approval.

Implementing a climate-related procurement strategy calls for practical supply and pricing arrangements. Our firm’s Energierechtler energy-law service (in German) provides further information on energy supply contracts, power purchase agreements and contractual support for energy projects.

Emissions data and commercial risks

Measurement, calculation, verification and documentation must suit the relevant system. Where several businesses use the same data, their origin, verification status and permitted use should be clear. Estimates and methodological changes require particular care. Technical experts are involved where emissions or installation parameters are disputed.

Contracts must identify who bears additional costs, inaccurate data and delays. A general price adjustment clause does not necessarily cover every change in carbon costs. Nor can force majeure or economic unreasonableness be inferred solely from rising climate costs. The particular agreement and statutory conditions are decisive.

Proceedings and remedies

Decisions concerning emissions obligations, permits or adverse orders require assessment of the remedies under the relevant legislation. An administrative challenge with a separate interim application is often necessary. Tax and customs decisions may instead fall within the fiscal courts’ jurisdiction. The label “carbon levy” alone does not determine the correct route.

Contract disputes may involve payment, adjustment, performance or damages before civil courts or arbitral tribunals. An EU interpretation issue can be decisive in national proceedings. A possible reference to the Court of Justice of the European Union does not replace timely use of the national remedy.

Four practical examples

The following examples are illustrative scenarios, not accounts of completed client matters.

Example 1: Importing steel components

A business imports components from a non-EU country and receives conflicting emissions data. Product classification, responsibility and applicable CBAM rules are assessed. Reliable data and correction duties are added to the supply contract. The assessment also identifies which evidence must be available before the next import or filing.

Example 2: Electrifying a production installation

An operator intends to replace a fossil-fuel process. We coordinate the legal assessment of installation changes, grid connection, energy supply and funding. The sequence matters: an early order could jeopardise funding, while a new process must not start without necessary authorisation.

Example 3: A dispute over carbon costs

A supplier charges an additional climate-cost surcharge. The customer disputes its contractual basis. Calculation, incorporation of the clause and the adjustment mechanism are examined. A transparent cost allocation may be negotiated; a statutory cost increase does not automatically permit any unilateral price increase.

Example 4: A challenged emissions report

An authority considers data incomplete. We coordinate technical clarification, access to the file and a legal response. A subsequent binding decision requires review of challenge deadlines and enforceability. Ongoing discussions with a verifier do not prevent a statutory deadline from expiring.

Related topics

Contact

Your next step in ESG law.

Whether your matter concerns contracts, regulatory proceedings or a dispute, tell us what you need. We will clarify the legal issues and next steps with you.

horak Rechtsanwälte Partnerschaft mbB · Georgstraße 48 · 30159 Hannover