ESGrecht – horak Rechtsanwälte

Home / Strategy & reporting

Strategy & reporting

EU Taxonomy and sustainable economic activities

Whether an activity falls within the EU Taxonomy and whether it satisfies its requirements are different questions. We assist with legal assessment, supporting evidence and the use of Taxonomy statements in reports and contracts.

An activity assessment, not a blanket company label

The Taxonomy is a European classification system for economic activities. It does not award a general quality label to a company. Eligibility initially means that an activity is covered by the relevant criteria. Alignment additionally requires satisfaction of the applicable conditions. A low percentage therefore does not automatically mean that a business operates unlawfully.

The assessment distinguishes substantial contribution to an environmental objective, doing no significant harm to other objectives, technical screening criteria and minimum safeguards. The six environmental objectives concern climate mitigation, adaptation, water, circular economy, pollution prevention and biodiversity. The activity and applicable version of the delegated acts determine the relevant criteria.

Assessing technical evidence legally

The classification of an economic activity is checked against actual processes. Technical reports, energy performance certificates, permits and supplier records are evidence, but not necessarily complete proof of alignment. A certificate may demonstrate one aspect while leaving others unresolved. We therefore work with the relevant technical and commercial functions.

For “do no significant harm”, describing only a favourable environmental characteristic is insufficient. Potential adverse effects on other objectives also require assessment under the relevant framework. Minimum safeguards additionally require consideration of relevant corporate procedures. An installation’s environmental characteristics cannot be isolated from all social and organisational requirements.

Metrics, investment plans and contracts

Mandatory disclosures are governed by the applicable disclosure rules. Allocation of turnover, capital expenditure and operating expenditure must match the financial data. Double counting, boundaries between activities and changes in the consolidation perimeter are common issues. Simplifications and transitional provisions are assessed for the relevant reporting period.

Taxonomy terminology should be defined precisely in financing and acquisition agreements. Relevant matters include the reference version, date of evidence, verification, subsequent legislative changes and consequences of misclassification. An undertaking to provide documents differs from an unconditional warranty of lasting alignment. Public statements must also reflect these distinctions.

Proceedings and remedies

Contractual disputes over metrics may lead to payment, information or damages claims. Supervisory measures first require identification of the competent authority and applicable remedies. Misleading claims of Taxonomy alignment may additionally give rise to unfair competition injunctions. Questions of EU interpretation may reach the preliminary ruling procedure through a national court.

Four practical examples

The following examples are illustrative scenarios, not accounts of completed client matters.

Example 1: Financing a building

A bank requires a Taxonomy-aligned property. The energy performance certificate alone does not resolve every issue. We clarify the activity, evidence date, further technical criteria and contractual representations. An outstanding assessment is reflected as a condition or subsequent information obligation, rather than presented as an established characteristic.

Example 2: An installation with several functions

A manufacturer produces both covered and non-covered components. Turnover must be allocated to the activities transparently. Legal review supports the methodology and treatment of mixed production processes. A general reference to the industry does not substantiate the reported percentage.

Example 3: Buying an allegedly green portfolio

A data room contains a high Taxonomy percentage without complete supporting evidence. The buyer reviews calculations, technical documentation and exceptions. Unresolved matters are reflected in pricing mechanisms, warranties or indemnities. A general sustainability promise cannot replace a verifiable agreement on characteristics.

Example 4: Criteria change during the contract

European screening criteria change during a financing agreement. Whether this constitutes a breach depends on the agreed reference and adjustment clause. We assess notification duties and a workable amendment. Old and new metrics should be distinguished clearly rather than retrospectively mixing different methods.

What the assessment requires

An activity description, the relevant version of the criteria, technical evidence, metric calculations and draft agreements form the basis. A dispute also requires the original representations, review reports and change notifications.

Related topics

Contact

Your next step in ESG law.

Whether your matter concerns contracts, regulatory proceedings or a dispute, tell us what you need. We will clarify the legal issues and next steps with you.

horak Rechtsanwälte Partnerschaft mbB · Georgstraße 48 · 30159 Hannover