Strategy & reporting
CSRD, ESRS and sustainability reporting
Sustainability reports must reflect the business, reporting year and applicable legal framework. We assess reporting duties, responsibilities, statements and liability risks at the intersection of company law and European regulation.
Who has to report?
The starting point is the applicable national legislation and European directives. Legal form, group structure, capital market status, size criteria and financial year affect classification. Exemption through group reporting and special rules for non-EU groups may also be decisive. Describing a company as “subject to the CSRD” without specifying the year and legal basis is therefore often imprecise.
Amending Directive (EU) 2026/470 substantially changed the European framework. In particular, it provides for a narrower ordinary scope covering more than 1,000 employees and more than EUR 450 million in net turnover. These EU requirements must be compared with national implementation and transitional law; they do not automatically replace every existing German reporting duty. A definitive assessment therefore requires a current review for the entity and reporting period concerned.
Materiality and substantiated statements
The ESRS structure sustainability reporting. Double materiality considers the undertaking’s impacts on people and the environment alongside financial risks and opportunities for the undertaking. Legal support assesses whether the evaluation is documented coherently, responsibilities are appropriate and published statements are supported by the available data.
A report needs clear boundaries. Estimates, data gaps, changes in methodology and value chain information should not disappear behind general statements. Forward-looking statements must distinguish the starting position, assumptions and measures. Legal review replaces neither technical emissions calculations nor the statutory assurance provided by an authorised independent body.
Approval, assurance and correction
A reliable process connects data collection with technical review and legal approval. The management report, website, financing documents and product advertising are checked for inconsistencies. Different publications should not, for example, convey different meanings of the same climate target. Trade secrets need protection without undermining mandatory disclosure.
If an error is discovered after publication, its extent and significance should be assessed systematically. Amending the website alone does not necessarily discharge duties to correct other documents. Relevant bodies, communications with assurance providers, disclosure and possible capital market information duties must be examined. The response and its factual basis are documented.
Proceedings and liability risks
Depending on the duty and type of undertaking, disclosure and coercive fine proceedings, accounting enforcement, supervisory measures or civil claims may arise. The specific decision, rather than the ESG label, determines the challenge available. Coercive fine proceedings follow different rules from administrative court litigation; investor claims require a separate analysis.
Internally, recourse against officers or service providers may become relevant. Externally, misleading statements may also infringe unfair competition law. An incorrect metric does not automatically entitle every reader to compensation: a legal basis, breach, attribution, loss and causation must each be established.
Four practical examples
The following examples are illustrative scenarios, not accounts of completed client matters.
Example 1: Reassessing the size thresholds
A group previously expected to enter a later reporting wave reassesses its position after the EU changes. Employee figures, turnover, consolidation perimeter and transitional rules are documented. Even if a statutory duty falls away, banks may continue to require contractually defined information, which is treated separately from a statutory sustainability report.
Example 2: An unsubstantiated climate target
A draft report promises complete elimination of emissions by a particular year, but the measures only address part of the emissions. The statement is refined by reference to accounting boundaries, reduction measures and assumptions. The same standard is then applied to presentations and the corporate website to avoid inconsistent communications.
Example 3: An error by a data provider
An external service provider supplies an incorrect energy consumption figure. Before publication, the correction and audit trail are secured. After publication, correction and notification duties also need assessment. The services agreement is examined for scope, review obligations and liability limitations; outsourcing does not generally remove responsibility for the report.
Example 4: Information from a small supplier
A customer requests extensive social and environmental data. The supplier establishes which information is provided by law, contract or voluntarily. Protections for smaller businesses and applicable voluntary standards are considered. Confidential employee information should not be passed into the customer’s report without assessment.
Documents and next steps
Useful documents include the size assessment, group chart, materiality analysis, data catalogues, review records and all drafts. If there is a challenge, we also need the complete notice, including evidence of service and information about available remedies.
Further reading and legal sources
Taxonomy · ESG data · Governance. Amending Directive (EU) 2026/470 · German Environment Agency: sustainability reporting.
Legal position: 15 November 2026. General information does not replace an assessment of the individual case. Deadlines, transitional provisions, admissibility and representation requirements must be checked against the particular decision and procedural circumstances.
Related topics
Contact
Your next step in ESG law.
Whether your matter concerns contracts, regulatory proceedings or a dispute, tell us what you need. We will clarify the legal issues and next steps with you.
horak Rechtsanwälte Partnerschaft mbB · Georgstraße 48 · 30159 Hannover
